[Wally]

I added #8.

Here's a clue. One car so far belongs to someone who was NOT in the identity parade.

[StanDaam]

Still say 4 is grat with this deduction...

http://jalopnik.com/why-do-italian-alfas-wear-irish-shamrocks-1545666396

You don't go by the name Diesel elsewhere, do you Stan??
I just saw the following in the comments from Rolz' link;

Diesel>Jason Torchinsky
3/17/14 4:58pm
You'd be searching for lucky symbols too if you drove an Alfa. I'd bet that many a goat have been slaughtered before turning the key.

Goat oil!! My favourite lubricant... 

[Bruce]

#1 Bacculum
#2 ?
#3 ?
#4 ?
#5 Bruce - XGN Profile pic gave it away
#6 Wally
#7 Stan

hmmm, I just checked... my Avatar is a 1962 Mercury Comet Custom 4 Door Wagon
THAT PIC, is a 1963 Mercury Marauder S55... now that has thrown a spanner in the works.

[Bacchulum]

I saw #1 and thought "Bruce said he is a mechanic..." but then I saw #5 and "hell, that's exactly the car he would like, isn't it?"

So maybe #1 is Bacchulum the machinist and #5 is Bruce?

In any case: people, please guess. If you don't guess, Wally does not answer. And if he does not answer, there are no pieces of puzzle to put together!

I don't know if this will screw your theory, but I only worked as a machinist for a few years.
I'm actually a Mechanical Fitter (rebuilding train motors at the moment).

[Rolz]

hmmm, I just checked... my Avatar is a 1962 Mercury Comet Custom 4 Door Wagon
THAT PIC, is a 1963 Mercury Marauder S55... now that has thrown a spanner in the works.

Sorry Bruce... I was working off a small avatar photo
But I still this it's your car 

No other guesses? How close are we Wally?

AJ - car 8?

[grat]

I saw #1 and thought "Bruce said he is a mechanic..." but then I saw #5 and "hell, that's exactly the car he would like, isn't it?"

So maybe #1 is Bacchulum the machinist and #5 is Bruce?

In any case: people, please guess. If you don't guess, Wally does not answer. And if he does not answer, there are no pieces of puzzle to put together!

I don't know if this will screw your theory, but I only worked as a machinist for a few years.
I'm actually a Mechanical Fitter (rebuilding train motors at the moment).

Still infinitely closer to building cars than anything I have ever done...

[slideways]

#1 Bacculum
#2 ?
#3 ?
#4 ?
#5 Bruce - XGN Profile pic gave it away
#6 Wally
#7 Stan

hmmm, I just checked... my Avatar is a 1962 Mercury Comet Custom 4 Door Wagon
THAT PIC, is a 1963 Mercury Marauder S55... now that has thrown a spanner in the works.

The fact that you even know that gives the game away......

[AJ]

hmmm, I just checked... my Avatar is a 1962 Mercury Comet Custom 4 Door Wagon
THAT PIC, is a 1963 Mercury Marauder S55... now that has thrown a spanner in the works.

Sorry Bruce... I was working off a small avatar photo
But I still this it's your car 

No other guesses? How close are we Wally?

AJ - car 8?

I don't want to give any of the game away, but I had to laugh at that. I currently have no car due to having no actual paid employment 

Also, I wouldn't own an SUV if my life depended on it. My Mrs having a Subaru Forester is bad enough!

[Rolz]

I don't want to give any of the game away, but I had to laugh at that. I currently have no car due to having no actual paid employment 

Also, I wouldn't own an SUV if my life depended on it. My Mrs having a Subaru Forester is bad enough!

clutching at straws

[Wally]

I added car #9.

From this guess:

1. Bacculum (Just based on what grat said)
2. Stan
3. Phil
4. Grat
5. Bruce
6. Wally
7. Bird

There are only 3 correct.

[Freezer]

1. Freezer
2. Rolz
3. Wally - only cause I know he has kids
4. Grat Bird
5. Bruce
6. Joe
7. StanDaam

I'm definately not a ute driver . .

[grat]

I added car #9.

From this guess:

1. Bacculum (Just based on what grat said)
2. Stan
3. Phil
4. Grat
5. Bruce
6. Wally
7. Bird

There are only 3 correct.

But we know that Bird is not 7 and Phil is not 3. And we also now know (thanks to the "say whatever about my face but leave my car alone" rule) that freezer is not 1.

Still not much info, but 2 of these 4 are correct:

1. Bacchulum
2. Stan
4. Grat
6. Wally

and we know
1. not Freezer
3. not Phil
5. Bruce
7. not Bird

we are going slow, but starting to make a bit of progress

[marty]

Still not much info, but 2 of these 4 are correct:

1. Bacchulum
2. Stan
4. Grat
6. Wally

and we know
1. not Freezer
3. not Phil
5. Bruce
7. not Bird

we are going slow, but starting to make a bit of progress

So we can say 1 of these 3 are correct. 

1. Bacchulum
2. Stan
6. Wally

Im fairly sure you would guess yourself correctly and you have said thats your car in the past. Not even going into racial stereotyping this time.

[Phil.8]

1. Phil or is it mwhahaha
2. Stan
3. Bacchulum
4. Grat
5. Bruce
6. Wally
7. GB
8. Marty
9. Rolz

[Freezer]

But we know that Bird is not 7 and Phil is not 3. And we also now know (thanks to the "say whatever about my face but leave my car alone" rule) that freezer is not 1.

and we know
1. not Freezer
3. not Phil
5. Bruce
7. not Bird

True, but I am in there......!
(time to start dropping a few clues I think)