[grat]

There are 3 reddish cars: 2, 3, and 6. But we know that 6 is Wally, so Rolz is either 2 or 3.

Also, Rolz was mentioned as 9, which can't be, and 4 were correct: so this means that one and only one of these are correct:

1. Phil
2. GB
3. Joe
7. Freezer
8. Gratulin

As usual, the recap:
1. either Gratulin, GB, Joe, Phil
2. either Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz, Phil
3. either Freezer, Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz
4. Grat
5. Flattop
6. Wally
7. either Freezer,  Gratulin, GB, Joe, Phil
8. either  Gratulin, GB, Joe, Phil
9. either  Gratulin, GB, Joe, Phil

Sry, got me wrong....

Kabooom! So when you said

But we know that Bird is not 7 and Phil is not 3. And we also now know (thanks to the "say whatever about my face but leave my car alone" rule) that freezer is not 1.

and we know
1. not Freezer
3. not Phil
5. Bruce
7. not Bird

True, but I am in there......!
(time to start dropping a few clues I think)

"but I am in there" you simply meant you sent a picture. Not that you were in the list you quoted!

Mate, as punishment for your confusing statement you should go now buy a ute and drive nothing else for the rest of your life---even in sims!

[Freezer]

"and we know
1. not Freezer"              TRUE

"but I am in there"        Yes, my car is in there somewhere!

[Joe]

Well number 3 has gotta be someone with kids? And me guessing says it's not mine.

Judging by Freezers profile pic he's got kids, so... Number 3: Freezer?

[grat]

"and we know
1. not Freezer"              TRUE

"but I am in there"        Yes, my car is in there somewhere!

Are you saying that you are neither 3 nor 7, or you misread what I wrote before?

[Freezer]

"and we know
1. not Freezer"              TRUE

"but I am in there"        Yes, my car is in there somewhere!

Are you saying that you are neither 3 nor 7, or you misread what I wrote before?

I dont want to give it away, but lets just say no one has guessed mine yet!

[grat]

"and we know
1. not Freezer"              TRUE

"but I am in there"        Yes, my car is in there somewhere!

Are you saying that you are neither 3 nor 7, or you misread what I wrote before?

I dont want to give it away, but lets just say no one has guessed mine yet!

Step 1 of following Freezer's lead: Freezer is number 2
Proof: you have been guessed to be 1, 8, 9, 7, 3. And we also know you are not 4, 5 or 6 as they have been identified. There remains only number 2.

[grat]

Step 2 of following Freezer lead: Since we know that Rolz is red, there are three red cars (2, 3, and 6), and Wally is 6 and Freezer is 2, then

Rolz is 3!!! Man, that comes as a big surprise to me...

[Rolz]

Step 2 of following Freezer lead: Since we know that Rolz is red, there are three red cars (2, 3, and 6), and Wally is 6 and Freezer is 2, then

Rolz is 3!!! Man, that comes as a big surprise to me...

Haha nice one grat... yes, it's ready for the kids but for now it's perfect for windsurfing gear

my 2 passions... windsurfing and simracing 



Now fully loaded! 6 Boards, 8 sails, 5 masts, 3 booms and all the rest... perfect fit!

[grat]

Nice Rolz!

There is another thing bothering me here. Follow me:

1. Freezer is 2;
2. Freezer was  not in the identity parade;
3. When Wally added 8 he said "one so far was not in the identity parade".

We know also (if you followed me you know why) that exactly one of these are correct: Phil is 1 or Gratulin is 8. But Gratulin was not in the identity parade, so if Wally meant "only one so far was not in the identity parade" then we must conclude that:

Phil is 1 and Gratulin is 9!!!

[grat]

But then Joe was offended when someone suggested he drove a Toyota Altis, so he can't be 7. Also, GB cares about us knowing he drives a company car, perhaps with banners (hence the non-personal picture)

So ladies and gentlemen, if nobody lied:

1. Phil
2. Freezer
3. Rolz
4. Grat
5. Bruce
6. Wally
7. GB
8. Joe
9. Gratulin

Let me say right now that this looks really strange to me. I would not have guessed Gratulin to be 9! But he himself said that Wally gave a big hint when he added the last two cars, so it sounds like I collectedly interpreted Wally's hint. Furthermore, Phil being 1 makes kind of sense...

[Guybrush Threepwood]

I can confirm that nobody lied.

[grat]

I can confirm that nobody lied.

Stop confusing me!

[StanDaam]

Grat the Super Sleuth!!

[Guybrush Threepwood]

Now we just wait for Wally.  Although I think you have at least one wrong, Grat.

[grat]

Now we just wait for Wally.  Although I think you have at least one wrong, Grat.

Which means I have at least two of them wrong
As I wrote: they are pretty strange indeed. But then again, even Rolz being 3 was strange, and then it worked. What is sure is:

2. Freezer
3. Rolz
4. Grat
5. Bruce
6. Wally

Anything wrong in there is Freezer's fault

The next step was setting Gratulin as strictly greater than 8. But this is due to an interpretation of a hint by Wally, when he said "one is not from the identity parade" I interpreted it as only one (Freezer). But if either I misinterpreted or he forgot, then it does not hold anymore and we are back to:

One of these is surely correct, but only one: 1 is Phil, Gratulin is 8

1. Phil or Gratulin or GB or Joe
7. Phil or Gratulin or GB
8. Phil or Gratulin or GB or Joe
9. Phil or Gratulin or GB or Joe

This is all the info I have.