Then, if we buy the theory that Grat is 4, since Stan and Bacchulum are not in the list, it means that 6 is Wally!!!
Flattop = 5
Freezer = 3 or 7
Grat (they say)= 4
Gratulin ?
Guybrush ?
Joe ?
Phil is not 3
Rolz is not 7
Wally = 6
Said otherwise:
1. either Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz, Phil
2. either Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz, Phil
3. either Freezer, Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz
4. Grat
5. Flattop
6. Wally
7. either Freezer, Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz, Phil
8. either Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz, Phil
9. either Gratulin, GB, Joe, Rolz, Phil